Review: And Sometimes Why by Rebecca Johnson


From Publishers Weekly

Vogue contributing editor Johnson examines in her heartbreaking debut the ties that bind and break in the face of tragedy. Darius, a Shakespeare scholar and professor, and his wife, Sophia, head of membership at a local art museum, are mired in the banal ebb-and-flow of family life they share with their two teen daughters—bookish Miranda and imperious social butterfly Helen. A sisterly tussle over use of the family car ends with Miranda attending college orientation and finding herself attracted to fellow freshman-to-be Jason, and Helen, while riding on the back of her just-dumped boyfriend’s motorcycle, getting into a horrific traffic accident. As Helen lies in the ICU suspended between life and death, the author gives voice to the people Helen has touched: Darius and Sophia find little solace in each other; Harry Harlow, the game show host who was involved in Helen’s accident, witnesses his life falling apart; and Miranda awkwardly navigates the feelings Jason has stirred within her. While the wandering focus on disparate characters pulls the novel in unwieldy directions (as when Miranda drops out to follow her boyfriend to Alaska), Johnson’s portrayal of a family’s grieving is exquisitely crafted. (Jan.)

And Sometimes Why by Rebecca Johnson came out on Valentine’s Day, February 14th, but I was lucky enough to win an advance copy from  I devoured this book in less than 48 hours.  I’m not sure if I can come up with the right words to do this novel justice.  

It is a gripping tale of what happens to a family after a tragic accident puts their lives into a state of suspended animation.  Watching this family fall apart reminded me in many ways of Jacqueline Michard’s The Deep End of the Ocean because in both cases, the parents are left to deal with a child who is not dead, but is in every other way gone.

Each family member comes to terms with the tragedy differently and in their own time.   The grieving parents’ relationship is torn apart as they disagree over their daughter’s care.  The distraught sister is the one who asks the hard questions and is the most realistic.  She moves from the family home in California to Alaska with her boyfriend. One day on a walk she encounters a fox in a trap, still alive but suffering.  She decides to put it out of it’s misery with her own hands.  Afterwards.. “Each time she glanced down at the body.. she felt her horror fade a tiny bit.  A body without life was an empty container.  Nothing to be afraid of.  Nothing to weep over.”

Ms. Johnson has done a great job of making her characters believable.  They seem so real to me.  It is a heartbreaking and compelling story, and so well written that it’s hard to believe it’s a first novel.

A book club would find much to discuss from And Sometimes Why (discussion questions can be found HERE).  The ending is open ended and I find myself wondering what the characters would do next.  This is a remarkable book and one I would highly recommend.

I’ve received an email from the author, and she is talking with the publisher to see if we can do a giveaway of this book here at Books on the Brain.  I’m hoping she will also agree to an interview.  Check back soon for details.  


7 Responses

  1. Gosh, this book sounds excellent! I’m glad the only thing I drooled on was myself while reading your review! 🙂

  2. Your review makes me want to read this so much! I will be the first in line if you are doing a giveaway!

  3. Great review. I would definitely be interested in winning a copy of this book, so keep us posted!

  4. Great review ~ now, I just have to finish the other 5 books I have on my nightstand so I can read “And Sometimes Why” 😉

  5. Wow, sounds good, I’d never heard of it before and it is a lot the book I have in the Amazon contest! Including a couple of the character names. Weird. I love Jackie Mitchard. She was kind enough to rate and review my contest excerpt. I’m starting a meme on my blog and I tagged you. I hope you’ll play along:)

  6. Sounds wonderfully melodramatic! This will have to go on my TBR list which is up to about 400 novels, give or take.

  7. Thanks for all the kind comments! I’m still waiting to hear back from the author.. she is currently traveling in Argentina. Bookbabie, what an odd coincidence. In your book, though, we’re able to know the thoughts of the character in a coma (a fabulous and interesting phenomena).. not so here. Chartroose, you may want to move this one up to the top of your list, it really is that good.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: