Review: In A Perfect World by Laura Kasischke

In-a-Perfect-World-199x300It’s the end of the world as we know it… and I feel fine.. that song kept running through my head as I was reading this book..

In a Perfect World by Laura Kasischke is a story set in the near future.  It’s a dystopian family drama, with a growing sense of doom extending right through to the very end.

Jiselle is a busy flight attendant who, at 32 years of age, has been a bridesmaid six times. After one particularly difficult evening at work (seven hours in a plane full of passengers that never left the runway) she is sitting in an airport bar, sipping a glass of wine, when a gorgeous pilot, Captain Mark Dorn, takes notice of her.  Three months later, after a whirlwind courtship, they become engaged.

It’s on the afternoon of Mark and Jiselle’s engagement that they see the white balloons for the first time.  One balloon for every victim of the Phoenix flu.  Groups in every major American city are releasing white balloons.  Are they a compassionate expression of concern, or a political statement and condemnation of the current administration in the White House?  The media can’t decide.

And when Mark and Jiselle go out of the country for their honeymoon, they are warned that people aren’t renting rooms to Americans.  Taxi drivers won’t drive Americans. Jiselle and Mark view it all as a minor inconvenience rather than any kind of true threat. The Phoenix flu, reminiscent of swine flu or bird flu, is spreading across America and beyond. Fear and panic are taking hold throughout the world and Americans are being shunned wherever they go.  But Mark and Jiselle are in love *cue the angels* so they don’t focus on that.

Before Jiselle knows what hit her she is living in Mark’s log cabin and stepmom to his three children.  Everything is picture-perfect.  Unfortunately, Mark’s daughters hate her and make no effort to hide it, but Mark’s little boy Sam is a sweetie and they form a bond.

The new family has some adjustment issues.  Jiselle quits her job to take care of the kids, and Mark, due to his flight schedule, is frequently absent.  The older girls are horrible to Jiselle but she remains kind to them.  The family situation reaches a crisis level and their marriage is put to the test when Mark, after a flight to Germany, is quarantined for months in that country. Even though the kids and Jiselle are still getting to know one another, they must rely on each other as the flu becomes a pandemic and the outlook is dire.  Will the family survive?

This isn’t an easy review to write because the book has a bit of an identity crisis.  Is it a ripped-from-the-headlines tale about a flu epidemic?  Yes.  Is it a romance?  Sort of.  A family drama? Sure.  Just when I thought the story would go down one path, it went down another.  I was most drawn into the story line about the pandemic.  I’ve got the swine flu symptoms memorized and my kids never leave the house without hand sanitizer, so I read that part with fascination and dread.  The fact that something like this could happen (is happening) makes it scary.  The author included plenty of information surrounding the flu and the spread of disease to make it timely and realistic.

But the reading experience wasn’t intense.  I wasn’t on the edge of my seat.  I thought Jiselle was a little silly, worrying more about her relationship (‘he hasn’t called.. what does it mean?’) when there were much bigger things to worry about, like how they would survive.  I was less interested in the romance and subsequent family drama than about the pandemic, and when Jiselle would blather on about how handsome Mark was, it was all I could do not to skim and skip ahead to get back to the sections about the flu.  It felt like two separate stories, with the one being much more compelling than the other.

I liked this book for the beautiful writing.  It was a quick read that I didn’t put down until I had finished it.  But I didn’t care for the ending.  I don’t need a perfect ending but I do like to have something of a clue as to what happens.  It’s all left up to speculation, which would probably make it an excellent choice for a book club.  They could debate what happens to this family. They could give opinions on what, if anything, Jiselle heard at the end.

In a Perfect World isn’t perfect, however I would recommend this book to anyone interested in the subject matter.  It’s a thought provoking read and one I won’t soon forget.

For other opinions of the book, check out the rest of Laura Kasischke’s virtual book tour:

Monday, October 12th – Starting Fresh

Wednesday, October 14th – BookNAround

Thursday, October 15th – Book Club Classics!

Monday, October 19th – A Reader’s Respite

Friday, October 23rd – The Book Nest

Monday, October 26th – Galleysmith

tlc-logo-resizedThursday, October 29th – A High and Hidden Place

Monday, November 2nd – Word Lily

Tuesday, November 3rd – Books on the Brain

Thursday, November 5th – Write Meg

Many thanks to Trish for including me on this TLC Book Tour.


17 Responses

  1. At the beginning of the review, I was ready to log onto my library website and order it, But as you went on, I did sense an identity crisis. If the book is about a pandemic and the end of the world, then lay it on! Little side stories are OK (The Stand had them, right?) but not that overshadow the main plot. Great review though!

  2. I have been hearing about this books and leaning toward picking up a copy but am now leaning in the other direction. I usually like books to have more of a sense of what they are because I can get lost in the meanderings.

  3. I don’t like it when romance is focused on despite the threat of death. She’s got bigger fish to fry!

  4. I think it would be very chilling to read a book about something frightening that is going on right now- but too bad that it wasn’t more focused.

  5. I don’t like ambiguous endings either, so I probably won’t seek this book out.

  6. interesting. this is the first semi-negative review I’ve read of this one.

  7. Thanks for being on the tour, Lisa! Sorry it wasn’t for you. I’ll be curious to see what the author puts out next and whether *that* book will have more of a focus.

  8. What a timely read! Every week, we get a taped call from the schools about swine flu. ( I’m not really sure how I feel about the matter, and whether I think swine flu shots are in order.) Anyway, this book sounds interesting in regards to the pandemic. The presence of the Phoenix flu and unruly stepchildren might lessen the romantic aspects somewhat. Thanks for your thoughtful review.

  9. This one sounds interesting although based on your review it doesn’t feel like one I have to rush out and buy or read right away. I’m not always a fan of ambigous endings either so I will have to be in the mood to speculate before I read this!

  10. I’m so glad to see this review. I just picked this up yesterday and plan to start it tonight. : )

  11. I can’t decide if I want to read this or not. On the one hand it looks good, but on the other hand I am not sure if is for me…

  12. I, too, am one the fence about this book. On the one hand, the synopsis looks very intriguing, but on the other I am not so fond of books where the romance aspect begins to edge out the other parts of the story. Great review though!

  13. It sounds really good, but bummer about the ending. I may still pick it up, I don’t know.

  14. Yikes, I think I have less fear of the swine flu that getting trapped on a plane on a runway for 7 hrs, which is why I won’t fly. I does sound a bit ripped from the headlines. Thanks for the honest review

  15. I’m soon to be 90 yrs, and this book turned me off at first as an oversimplistic love story that would only bore me. Then I began to pickup on the nuances of a real 30’s depression story that will produce a new (old) way of life that heals the wrongs of what we have wrought. The depression did that in my day; we had a flu too, in 1918 into which I was born. Note the bad characters turning to good habits–the change to better language. The loving human relationships.
    I was spellbound–esp with the environmental aspect–and the suspense of how it would end. I think it ended with a promise of a healing of the times.

    • I agree with the reviewer, and with Elaine – it ended with a promise of healing. I cannot get this book out of my head, esp. with everything going on lately in the Middle East, Japan, the world economy, etc. A very good book.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: