Review: Peony in Love by Lisa See

Lisa See is a master at exploring ancient Chinese life, particularly the lives of women.  Set in 17th century China, Peony in Love is the story of how a privileged young girl from a wealthy family becomes a lovesick maiden, a hungry ghost, and eventually, an honored ancestor. 

The story opens with 16 year old Peony and her household preparing for a performance of the opera “The Peony Pavilion” which her father has staged and directed at great expense.  Visitors have arrived and there is much excitement.  The opera is performed over the course of several days, and the young unmarried women are permitted to view it only from behind a screen, because it would be improper for a man outside of their immediate families to see them. 

Peony, an only child, is educated and well loved, unlike many ‘useless’ girls of her time.  She is lovely with her tiny bound feet and delicate lily gait.  She has studied the opera, considered a danger by some, and has many opinions and feelings about it.  Through the screen she can see some of the guests and a section of the stage.  She glimpses a handsome young man in the audience and, during a particularly poignant scene, is overcome with emotion and needs to move about.  Quite by accident, she encounters this young man (a sensitive poet who was also moved by the scene) in a courtyard of her home.  Ashamed at being seen yet drawn to him, they have a few moments together boldly speaking about the opera.  

Peony finds a way to meet this young man twice more.  Her mother discovers she has been out, and fearing the appearance of impropriety, banishes the betrothed Peony to her room.  Though she never learns the poet’s name, Peony becomes obsessed with the idea of him.  Her father has already arranged a marriage for her but she is lovesick for her poet, consumed by thoughts of him and wishing to marry him.  Ever the dutiful daughter, she continues to prepare for her marriage but also begins a project based on The Peony Pavilion, obsessively recording her thoughts on love in the margins.  She starts refusing food and ignores the advice of her doctors.  Her mother, alarmed and desperate to make Peony well again, burns every edition of The Peony Pavilion that she can find in a vain attempt to shock Peony back into health.  By the time Peony realizes she has made a horrible mistake about her sensitive poet, she is on her deathbed and it is too late. 

But that is just the beginning of this love story.  Peony learns about yearning and romantic love as a young girl; she later discovers physical love as a hungry ghost, and ‘deep heart’ love as a sister-wife in the afterworld.  She finds a way to make her voice heard and to live on even after death. 

I was anxious to read this book after having read Lisa See’s Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, perhaps my favorite book of all time (definitely in my top 3).  It is beautifully written, historically accurate, well researched and artfully constructed.  It’s a very visual book; I could vividly see the scenes in my mind’s eye.  There are so many wonderful cultural details and rich descriptions of traditions, superstitions and ideas about the afterlife, the treatment of ancestors, foot binding (not nearly as intense as Snow Flower, thank goodness), women’s issues, marriage, writing, and everyday life that make this a truly absorbing novel.  I loved it and would recommend Peony in Love to anyone who enjoys historical fiction, or just a really good (tragic romantic asian ghost) story. 

My book club will have the great privilege of talking to Lisa See by speaker phone next Sunday at our meeting.  I’ll be sure to take notes and share the details here!

20 Responses

  1. Lovely review. Which one of the two books would you recommend for me?

  2. I’m anxious to read this book too! I’m glad you liked it; I’ve heard it was not as good as Snow Flower and the Secret Fan, which I loved, but Peony in Love sounds like it’s definitely worth a read.

  3. I love books set in Asia – maybe because I’ve never been there. I’m adding this to my wish list.

  4. I’ve heard mixed things about this one – no doubt from those who loved Snow Flower, as you did, and I did as well. In light of that, I’m glad to know you liked this, it’s in my TBR stack.

  5. This has been on my TBR list for awhile. My book club was on a China kick for a long time so I decided to wait.

    The other poster asked this but between the two books..which would you suggest I read first?

  6. I am so glad you enjoyed this one! I have heard mixed reviews about it. Snow Flower and the Secret Fan is one of my all time favorite books and I am looking forward to reading this one.

  7. Hi guys, thanks for the comments. Sheri and Ti, Snow Flower is without question my favorite of the two, but that doesn’t mean that Peony isn’t a great book, it is!! I hate to even compare them because they are very different. Snow Flower is more realistic while Peony is vividly imagined- 2/3rds of it takes place after Peony is dead and wandering the earth as a ghost. Both are beautifully written books. Read both of them!! LOL

  8. *Snow Flower and the Secret Fan* is one of my all-time favorites, too. I haven’t yet read *Peony in Love*, but I’ve had it on my radar … when will that 30-hour day be invented so we can read all these great books?!?

    I enjoyed your review! Yes, please share everything you learn from your book group’s conversation with Lisa See … that is so fun!

  9. Now I feel bad because I haven’t tried anything by her. I’ll have to buy a used copy of “Snow Flower…” and see if I like See!

  10. I was glad to see that you loved this book. I absolutely adored Snow Flower and am concerned that nothing will be as good! I have this book on my TBR shelf and look forward to reading it.

    How lucky you are to get to chat with Lisa See! I’ll be looking forward to reading how that went!

  11. Great review. I have both of these on my shelf-your review has made me want to move them to the front of the pile.

  12. What intrigues me the most about this novel is the details with which she describes the ghost marriage. I also feel a stab of dismay at the quality–how repressed and oppressed–of women’s lives in ancient China. Lisa See must have conducted very extensive research in writing this novel. Great review. 🙂

  13. i haven’t read any books by this author…but i’ll put this title on my list! thanks. 🙂

  14. I’m pretty sure I read her book Snow Flower and the Secret Fan before but I’m not sure.

  15. I loved both of these books. I’m envious that you’re going to get to talk to Lisa See. I thought she would be too “big” to have time for book clubs. Let us know how it goes.

  16. I’ve had this book for so long and I haven’t read it. Why? I have no idea. I need to read it. I am really looking forward to your book club notes with the author. I hope your time with her is really neat.

  17. What a great review! This sounds like an excellent read, and I’ve added it to my list.

  18. I love this book and couldn’t agree more that it’s beautifully written! It’s my first book by Lisa See. I haven’t read Snow Flower but it’s definitely on my wish list.

  19. […] Lisa at Books on the Brain […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: