Review: Summer People by Brian Groh

Summer People by Brian Groh is the story of Nathan, a self absorbed young man (and I use the term ‘man’ loosely) who works part time in a library in Cleveland. His dad hooks him up with a job as a caretaker for a few weeks to the elderly Ellen at her old-money summer home in an exclusive New England community.

Nathan quickly discovers Ellen’s situation is more complex than he originally thought. She’s been through some sort of accident the previous summer (no one is very forthcoming about what happened). Consequently, her behavior and personality have changed, and her mental stability is questionable. Nathan’s not sure he’s qualified to care for her, yet he stays on for selfish reasons. He doesn’t have much to go back to in his real life, so it’s just easier and more convenient for him to stay on.

Nathan doesn’t fit in well with the rich crowd.  He befriends Eldwin, a pastor who is there for the summer to serve the community.  Eldwin is a former punk rocker with a drinking problem, a depressed wife, and a cute nanny.  They go on walks, go kayaking, drink together, and talk about life.

A college dropout with few prospects, Nathan doesn’t have a lot going on. He’s immature and insecure, seeing events and people only as they relate to him. He’s lonely and sad, drinks a lot of rum and cokes, and lies to boost his self esteem.  He exaggerates his abilities and minor accomplishments in an attempt to impress others. He’s socially awkward and constantly comparing himself to the people around him.

He’s not much of a caretaker either. He does just the bare minimum of what he should for Ellen. They do a lot of tv watching. They kill time by taking drives and occasionally going to the club to watch tennis. Once vibrant, beautiful, and popular, Ellen is a shell of her former self. Nathan is forever waiting for Ellen to take a nap in her chair or go off to bed so he can leave the house to see his “girlfriend”, who he believes he is falling in love with, but in truth, barely knows.

Things happen. A house burns down. Nathan gets the snot kicked out of him. He has sex with his love interest. A small boat sinks. There are a couple of love triangles, a fall and a ride in an ambulance. Yet even with these dramatic elements, the book feels sort of flat and one dimensional.

This is a frustrating book, because at the end, nothing has changed. Nathan hasn’t learned anything or grown up one bit. Ellen is still a mystery. I had no deeper understanding of the characters at the close of the book than I had in the beginning.

I think Ellen’s story would have been much more interesting than Nathan’s, with her failed romances and suicide attempts, her colorful past and boatload of money. People whisper about her when she walks into a room.  I wished throughout the book that her character could have been more fully imagined and developed. Summer People is Brian Groh’s debut novel, and while I think he has a ton of potential, this book never fully takes off.

Summer People is another book with at least two different covers. The one with the oars is the cover for Target’s Bookmarked Book Club. I doubt I ever would have picked up the one with the legs.

Which do you prefer?



11 Responses

  1. Interesting covers. I think the first one makes it look like “literature” while the second one definitely conveys a chick-lit vibe. I would deifintely have guessed that the one with the legs was the Target book club version.

  2. You put into words my thoughts exactly…. but now you have done all the work, what is left to talk about at the book club meeting? By the way, the “legs” version made me laugh out loud – honestly too sexy for this book.

  3. I would definitely choose the first cover over the second. The one with the legs makes it look so flighty – and what on earth does that have to do with an elderly woman??

  4. Love the first cover (that’s why I bought the book) although I hope I like it better than you!

  5. Bookmama says what I was thinking. I liked the first cover.

  6. Hi guys, thanks for the comments. I agree the cover with the oars says “Literature” and the cover with the legs says “Sexy”. This book wasn’t sexy!

    Sara, there is still much to talk about. I didn’t mention the Ralph character or much about Leah, or Thayer or Kendra. Nothing here really about Mr. McAllister either. So we’ll have something to discuss. Plus I look forward to hearing everyone else’s impressions of the book, and to picking books for the spring!!

    Stephanie, you might love the book! I look forward to hearing what you think of it.

  7. […] love books and love to talk about them! We discussed Summer People by Brian Groh. If you read my review, you know I didn’t love the book, so I was a little worried about the meeting, because we had […]

  8. I agree completely. I would not have picked up the book if I had seen the legs hanging out of the boat.

    And by the way, I loved the way the book ended.

  9. I didnt even know there were two covers until this sight. i got mine at Target and interestingly enough, the oars caught my eye and i didnt een read the whole back o f the book until i got home. if i saw the legs one i dont think i would have been as inclined to pick it up, the oars leave the potential reader curious as to whats written inside

  10. Tank, really?? What was it that you loved? To me it was just.. more of the same. I felt like saying, “Have we learned nothing here, Nathan??”

    Kris, I’m with you. Never would I have picked up the legs cover. Thanks for the comment.

  11. I like the first cover better.. my friend let me borrow this book and i read it about 3 months later haha. I liked this book till the last chapter.. I wanted it to continue but i don’t think it ended on a good note..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: