Review: The Jane Austen Book Club by Karen Joy Fowler

The Jane Austen Book Club by Karen Joy Fowler is about a loosely connected group of people who form a club to discuss Austen’s work. Each chapter highlights one of her novels and the life of one of the book club members. 5 of the members are women and rabid Austen fans. The sixth member, a man, is new to her work and reads science fiction (gasp!). Poor guy is judged on everything, including his offerings to pot luck dinners.

As a book club member myself, I was interested to read this, but the sections when the characters are at their book club meetings weren’t that interesting. The conversation was haphazard and stilted. Sometimes they’d take phone calls, leave the room for long stretches of time, etc. during their meetings. We don’t do that at my book club. They would make judgments on members based on opinions or comments they made about Jane Austen. I haven’t read any Jane Austen, so I’m sure I would have been seen as unforgivably ignorant. Even though they were Austen snobs, the commentary on the novels seemed superficial and shallow.

The book is more character driven than plot driven, although I don’t think Fowler went deep enough into the characters for the reader to really care about them. They are sketched out enough to create interest, but I wanted to be pulled in further and the book just doesn’t do that.

It’s not necessary to be an Austen fan to read this book. No prior knowledge is required (although maybe it would help). A brief synopsis of her work is given at the back of the book for easy reference. I can’t be entirely sure, but I think there was an effort to mirror some present day situations going on with her characters to the characters in Austen’s novels. I was only vaguely aware of that, if in fact that was actually intended.

I had a problem with the narration. It kept changing without any rhyme or reason, mid chapter. I would think I knew who was “talking”, let’s say Jocelyn. Then it would say, “And Jocelyn did blah, blah, blah” and I would think, WHAT? I thought this was Jocelyn talking! I would have to go back to figure out who was narrating, and sometimes it was impossible to know. This was highly annoying and happened 3 or 4 times (I marked the pages so that I can complain at my own book club meeting!)

There was one part of the book that I connected with, and it was near the end, when Sylvia, a woman in her 50’s, misses her boys.. not her grown up sons but her boys when they were small. While looking at their dad, who she is separated from, she has flashback memories of camping trips and pulling her kids onto her lap to read and taking the training wheels off their bikes. Her reflections on their childhoods caught me by surprise as perhaps the most realistic moment in the book. As a mom of kids that are growing way too fast, I could relate to that. I miss my babies.

Everything is happily wrapped up in the end. We find out in the final few pages what happens to all the club members. The Jane Austen Book Club is ok, pleasant enough, not offensive, but not one I would recommend for book clubs. It’s too “light” for a book club read. If you’re an Austen fan and feel you must read it, I recommend you save your money and get it from the library.

The Jane Austen Book Club movie comes out on DVD February 5th. I noticed on my copy of the book that the actors all look about 10 years younger than they’re supposed to be. Hollywood!

8 Responses

  1. Nice review – Very well written.

  2. Great review — I didn’t love the book but maybe I missed something. Please let me know how your book club discussion goes! Thanks for link on your blogcall.

  3. I thought the book was enjoyable, but there was not a lot of depth to it. When I read it, I was the main person for a book club in Durham. I found myself feeling frustrated with folks who would show up and not read or just not respond to e-mail messages. Maybe that is whay I enjoyed the judgement some of the characters made about each other 🙂

  4. I just happen to be reading this book, so I had to not read your entire post as not to spoil it! 🙂 I’ll come back later to see what you have to say and to throw my feedback.

  5. HI guys, thanks for the comments. I wanted to like this book, and I tried to, but it just fell short, kwim?

  6. I FINALLY finished this book after getting back from my mom’s house. I thought it was just ok… maybe because I’ve never read Austen, and the only references I got was from watching a few of the movies?

    I re-read your post and see that the book was also made into a movie? I’m over to to check it out.

  7. Jenefur, I actually liked the movie a lot better than the book. How often does that happen?? Stephanie at THe Written Word did a review on it too and also liked the movie better, so you might want to check it out.

  8. I know I’m really after the fact on this comment, but I totally agree with you about this novel! By the end of the book, I really couldn’t have cared less about any of Fowler’s characters. They were all shadows or sketches of people, rather than fully-fleshed-out and interesting people. I’m a huge Austen fan, and was totally disappointed in this one! But I have to admit I enjoyed the film 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: